Islanders at Maple Leafs Pick, Odds & Prediction – NHL, October 17

Islanders at Maple Leafs

Sat, Oct 17, 7:10 PM ET · Status: Final · Scotiabank Arena, Toronto, ON

Final: Islanders 4, Maple Leafs 1

Our pick and the result

Pick: Toronto Maple Leafs, posted at -141

Market favorite on the moneyline. Published Oct 16, 2026, 1:03 PM ET, before the start.

  • Our pick: Toronto Maple Leafs -141, Lost

Price check

  • Our price: -141, published Oct 16, 2026, 1:03 PM ET
  • Best price, as of Nov 22, 12:04 PM ET: Closed
  • Win chance (no vig) then: 57%
  • Win chance (no vig), as of Nov 22, 12:04 PM ET: not available

Islanders at Maple Leafs closing odds

Each sportsbook's last price before the start.

Islanders at Maple Leafs: closing moneyline
SportsbookIslandersMaple Leafs
OpenOFFOFF
MyBookie+108-132
Bovada+110-130
BetOnline+109-123
BetUS-101-119
Islanders at Maple Leafs: closing spread
SportsbookIslandersMaple Leafs
OpenOFFOFF
MyBookie+1.5 -222-1.5 +178
Bovada+1.5 -233-1.5 +190
BetOnline+1.5 -227-1.5 +189
BetUS+1.5 -227-1.5 +192
Islanders at Maple Leafs: closing total
SportsbookOverUnder
OpenOFFOFF
MyBookie6 -1206 -101
Bovada6 -1256 +105
BetOnline6 -1206 +105
BetUS6 -1206 +100

Prices from MyBookie, BetOnline, Bovada and BetUS. Compare the 7 offshore sportsbooks.

American odds. The best closing price on each side is in bold when at least two sportsbooks had a price. OFF: the book had no closing price.

Line moves

No line moves yet. A move shows here once at least two sportsbooks agree on a new spread or total.

Matchup

Recent results

Islanders

  • L 1-2 at Ottawa Senators, October 15
  • W 3-2 vs Vancouver Canucks, October 13
  • L 3-5 vs Tampa Bay Lightning, October 10
  • W 4-1 vs Chicago Blackhawks, October 8
  • L 2-5 at New York Rangers, October 6

Maple Leafs

  • L 4-5 vs Buffalo Sabres, October 15
  • L 4-5 at Utah Mammoth, October 13
  • W 6-3 at Colorado Avalanche, October 10
  • L 3-4 at Vegas Golden Knights, October 8
  • W 5-4 vs Nashville Predators, October 6

Head to head

  • September 30, 2026: New York Islanders 1, Toronto Maple Leafs 2
  • April 9, 2026: Toronto Maple Leafs 3, New York Islanders 5
  • March 17, 2026: New York Islanders 3, Toronto Maple Leafs 1
  • January 3, 2026: Toronto Maple Leafs 3, New York Islanders 4

Match preview

The Islanders won 4-1. Our pick on the Maple Leafs lost.

The Islanders have averaged 2.9 goals scored and 2.4 allowed in 7 games this season. Last time out, the Islanders lost to the Ottawa Senators 2-1. The Maple Leafs average 3.5 goals for and 3.5 against this season. Most recently, the Maple Leafs lost to the Buffalo Sabres, 5-4.

Next NHL games

Other NHL games on October 17

  • Devils at Capitals, Devils 2, Capitals 4, final
  • Hurricanes at Jets, Hurricanes 3, Jets 2, final
  • Canucks at Lightning, Canucks 2, Lightning 4, final
  • Kraken at Panthers, Kraken 3, Panthers 8, final
  • Rangers at Blue Jackets, Oct 17, 7:10 PM ET
  • Stars at Blackhawks, Stars 4, Blackhawks 0, final
  • Sabres at Canadiens, Oct 17, 7:10 PM ET
  • Senators at Flyers, Senators 1, Flyers 3, final
  • Sharks at Red Wings, Oct 17, 7:10 PM ET
  • Blues at Predators, Blues 2, Predators 5, final
  • Bruins at Kings, Bruins 4, Kings 1, final
  • Penguins at Golden Knights, Penguins 2, Golden Knights 6, final
  • Oilers at Mammoth, Oilers 6, Mammoth 2, final

All NHL picks · NHL odds

Islanders vs Maple Leafs FAQ

Who is favored in Islanders vs Maple Leafs?

The game is over: Islanders 4, Maple Leafs 1.

What is the spread for Islanders vs Maple Leafs?

The spread closed when the game started.

What is the over/under for Islanders vs Maple Leafs?

The over/under closed when the game started.

When and where is Islanders vs Maple Leafs?

The Islanders play the Maple Leafs on Saturday, October 17 at 7:10 PM ET at Scotiabank Arena, Toronto, ON.

21+ only. Sportsbook offers and availability vary by location. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-MY-RESET.